Searching for cottages for sale in Ontario under $500 000? From Muskoka to Kawartha and beyond, Ontario has a variety of affordable getaway properties perfect for seasonal use, remote work, or rental income.

Forgot password Extend Verify Contact

44 Island
Temagami Nipissing P0H 2H0

$320,000
Residential Freehold beds: 3 baths: 1.0

Main Photo: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 1: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 2: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 3: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 4: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 5: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 6: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 7: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 8: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 9: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 10: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 11: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 12: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 13: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 14: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 15: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 16: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 17: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 18: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 19: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 20: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 21: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 22: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Photo 23: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
Status:
Active
Prop. Type:
Residential Freehold
MLS® Num:
X12258576
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
1
Island 44, Lake Temagami - A Hidden Gem. Escape to the tranquility of Lake Temagami with this charming three-season cottage located on Island 44, a true hidden gem for nature lovers and outdoor enthusiasts. Tucked away in a quiet, peaceful corner of the lake, this property is ideal for those seeking privacy, great fishing, and the ultimate Northern Ontario retreat. Set on an island rich with mature trees and a rugged, natural landscape, this retreat offers an authentic cottage experience surrounded by beauty and serenity. Thoughtfully updated by the current owner, the cottage features a durable tin roof, a cozy screened-in porch perfect for enjoying your morning tea or coffee, and numerous improvements throughout. A bunkie on the property comfortably sleeps four, making it ideal for hosting family and friends. You'll also find a gazebo for relaxing in the shade or enjoying lakeside meals. With three docks for your boat, fishing gear, or lounging by the water, this property makes lake life effortless and unforgettable. Don't miss your opportunity to own a slice of island paradise on beautiful Lake Temagami!
Property Type:
Residential Freehold
Property Sub Type:
Other
Home Style:
1 1/2 Storey
Total Approx Floor Area:
700-1100
Lot Size:
2-4.99
Depth:
169'7"
Frontage:
212'
Direction Faces:
East
Bedrooms:
3
Bathrooms:
1.0
Kitchens:
1
Bedrooms Above Grade:
3
Kitchens Above Grade:
1
Rooms Above Grade:
5
Zoning:
Residential
Foundation:
Piers, Post & Pad, Wood
Roof:
Metal
Alternative Power:
Generator-Wired
Garage:
None
Garage Spaces:
0.0
Other Structures:
Gazebo, Out Buildings, Other
Parking Spaces:
0
Total Parking Spaces:
0.0
Family Room:
No
Possession Details:
Flexible
Pool:
None
HST Applicable To Sale Price:
Included In
Taxes:
$1,830.87 / 2024
Assessment:
$- / -
Temagami
Temagami
Nipissing
Beach, Campground, Lake Access, Marina, Wooded/Treed, Waterfront
Carpet Free, Other
Conservation Regulations
fridge, stove, beds, large blue slide, generator, large green canoe
Large black boat
Wood
Dock, Island
Direct
Clean, Deep, Mixed
Owned
North West
Bay, Trees/Woods, Lake, Marina
Direct, Partially Obstructive
By Water, Other
Lake Temagami
Lake
Bunkie
Private
Floor
Type
Size
Other
Main
Bedroom
10'10" × 8'6"
Carpet Free, Above Grade Window
Main
Kitchen
17'2" × 9'
Eat-in Kitchen
Second
Bedroom 2
14' × 9'6"
Carpet Free
Second
Loft
13' × 9'6"
Water Supply Types:
Lake/River
Central Vacuum:
No
Seller Property Info Statement:
No
Date Listed:
Jul 03, 2025
Original Price:
Previous Price:
  • Photo 1: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 1 of 23
  • Photo 2: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 2 of 23
  • Photo 3: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 3 of 23
  • Photo 4: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 4 of 23
  • Photo 5: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 5 of 23
  • Photo 6: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 6 of 23
  • Photo 7: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 7 of 23
  • Photo 8: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 8 of 23
  • Photo 9: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 9 of 23
  • Photo 10: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 10 of 23
  • Photo 11: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 11 of 23
  • Photo 12: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 12 of 23
  • Photo 13: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 13 of 23
  • Photo 14: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Bunkie exterior
  • Photo 15: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Bunkie interior
  • Photo 16: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Bunkie interior 2
  • Photo 17: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Gazebo
  • Photo 18: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Gazebo interior
  • Photo 19: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Outhouse
  • Photo 20: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 20 of 23
  • Photo 21: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 21 of 23
  • Photo 22: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 22 of 23
  • Photo 23: 44 Island in Nipissing: Temagami House for sale : MLS®# X12258576
    Photo 23 of 23

Virtual Tour

Listed by Century 21 Blue Sky Region Realty Inc., Brokerage
Data was last updated July 16, 2025 at 04:15 AM (UTC)
DARYL  KING
powered by myRealPage.com

What to Expect from Affordable Ontario Cottages

Cottages in this price range often include:

• 2-3 bedrooms with cozy interiors and rustic charm
• Waterfront access or proximity to lakes, trails, and parks
• Seasonal or winterized structures with wood-burning stoves
• Decks, firepits, and private outdoor space for relaxation

Why Cottages Under $500K Are in High Demand Across Ontario

• Ideal for families and retirees looking for a peaceful escape
• Lower property taxes and maintenance costs
• Potential for Airbnb or seasonal rental income
• Opportunities to renovate or build equity over time

Where to Find Cottages for Sale in Ontario Under $500 000

Look for listings in areas like Kawartha Lakes, Bancroft, Haliburton Highlands, Parry Sound, and Northern Ontario regions, where land and lakefront options still exist within this budget.

Explore More GTA Homes:

Each link provides updated listings and expert insights.

FAQs – Cottages for Sale Ontario Under $500 000

1. Are cottages under $500K move-in ready or fixer-uppers?
Many are seasonal and may require cosmetic updates, but move-in-ready options exist, especially outside major tourist zones.

2. Can I finance a cottage in this price range?
Yes. Financing is available, though terms may differ for seasonal vs. year-round cottages. Talk to your lender for details.

3. Are there waterfront cottages for under $500,000?
Yes, especially in less commercialized or northern regions, though they may be smaller or more rustic.

4. Can I rent out my cottage when I’m not using it?
Many buyers turn their cottages into part-time income properties, especially during summer and long weekends.